Does anyone know of good things to use for an anal toys. I'm trying to get some depth in me, but I can't afford to buy an actual toy.

I'd suggest something smooth and not plastic

some dog toys look like they would work

As long as no dogs use them x3

of course

<Insert joke about using the dog instead here>

so if you feel like you want some depth and have a condom kicking around grab the plunger stick it to the shower (clean plunger obviously) and start rocking- thats what i do

Not entirely sure if it's a good idea to stick something up there that's not specifically designed to go there, you know what I mean?
Hell, i've heard some stories of people fucking up the tissue down their from literally using standard dildos
be careful man, dont want that to happen to anyone

It was thought that every guys do it for fun and trying to let women fuck them in the ass with strap-on. Does it feel odd weird to you?

Normally I just use my hand and fist myself as that is as far as I can get my hand up there.

You should really try your local sex shop, dildos can be pretty cheap

Definitely marker.

I wouldn't recommend a DIY thing. Tearing your colon, or worse; perforating it, would be a very bad thing.

I suggest getting a plastic hair brush with a rounded-off/phallic looking handle and then lube it up with some body gel (I do this nearly every time I decide to take a bath, I of course, make sure that my anus is clean as possible before doing it).

I've pushed a beer bottle up a girl's ass before in a bathroom at a party. Start with the thin end then switch to the thick end in first.