Edge1
07/09/23 09:03AM
Users of rule34, what are your morals in regards to art/rule34? (Be civil)
What art on rule34 do you find to be immoral? What are your morals when it comes to fictional/controversial art? What are the requirements for you to consider an art piece to be "too far"? What is the breaking point for you? What crosses the line for you? Or do you have no boundaries when it comes to art?

Personally, I only think art/rule34 goes too far under the following conditions.

-Drawn porn of IRL children

(I don't really care for lolis or fictional characters that are based on real people so long as it isn't the actual person, nor is it damaging a child's psyche. So I only considered drawn porn of real children bad since it destroys a child's psyche because that kind of art actually has IRL mental consequences.)

-Revenge porn made to harass a certain person.

(Harassment is never okay under any circumstances.)

Other than that anything that falls under fiction is okay so long as you aren't someone like Shadman who actually harms the psyche of children and makes revenge porn or porn made to harass people. As for lolis, gore, or even porn of characters BASED ON (keyword: based on) real people. I don't really have an issue with it as it's fictional and harmless, and isn't porn of actual real children. Meaning a character like Sky from FNF is okay, but not an actual IRL child celebrity.

Meaning so long as you aren't harming actual children, making porn of actual children, or are making revenge porn or porn made to harass people, or any deepfakes. Make whatever the fuck you want as anything else shouldn't really harm anyone.

Also, as the title states, stay civil, you can disagree, but do not fight or harass people.
gusfring456
07/09/23 11:15AM
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them
ferrousflora
07/09/23 11:19AM
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them

Agreed, I cringe whenever I see porn of JaidenAnimations.
Edge1
07/09/23 11:20AM
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them


I can respect that, granted I personally think that if you're an adult that isn't harassed by it, and are able to ignore it, it shouldn't be an issue, but all and all I find your morals agreeable.
doltscanttag
07/09/23 12:17PM
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them

So about 99.8% of all people?
Edge1
07/09/23 12:20PM
doltscanttag said:
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them

So about 99.8% of all people?


That's the one flaw with the argument, a lot of people hate having porn of themselves drawn on rule34, but so long as we're adults with a developed brain and psyche and are able to ignore it, we can just move on with our lives.
ferrousflora
07/09/23 04:28PM
IIRC JaidenAnimations has made it clear she doesn't want porn drawn of her, and yet people do so anyway. I will say Drawn Jaiden is way more attractive in her Platinum Nuzlocke scarf and turtleneck than she's got any right to be.

The obvious ones (what 4chan euphemistically called "cheese pizza" back in the day and revenge porn) have been stated.

- no fictional children unless they've been visibly aged up (as in actually looking like adults, not just given ass and tiddies) Even if it's just drawings, that's not a thing that should be encouraged. This applies to furry/cub stuff too. Why the fuck would you do that to my boy Tulin?

- depictions of RL animals that cannot consent (and, for some reason, are always dogs, wolves, or horses. What, nobody wants any echidna dick?) A hominid fucking an anthro or something non humanoid is definitely weird, but as long as it passes the Harkness text (is it sexually mature? is it smart enough to consent? can it communicate consent, preferably in speech?) I can't really bitch.

- No guro, snuff, necro. Just...why? Don't answer that btw.

- There are other things I hate (raceplay to the point of bona fide racism, anything that's more about cruelty and the inflicting of suffering than actual sex, malicious cuckoldry, etc.) but they're less cut and dry, not to mention they make up at least 10% of this site.
Shaded_Cube
07/09/23 05:06PM
For the most part, I don't give a fuck want people make. I'm all for freedom of expression. Doesn't matter if like it or not, they can make it. I only delete things based on the rules. You think loli and shota offend me? I've been exposed to way too much for that.
CrunchyToast
07/09/23 07:13PM
I mean, I usually don't have any morals in terms of R34, since as long as its not TOO weird and I can jerk off to it then I'm fine with it, although there's occasionally that ONE post that just makes you go "Ew, no" and just instantly turns you off. I can't really give out any names since I'm mostly limitless, but just like everyone else sometimes I just come across that one post that manages to turn me off.
BadLogin
07/09/23 07:14PM
as long if its not illegal or the person being r34’ed is okay with it then im fine with it
anti_megumin
07/09/23 07:15PM
No AI art
Edge1
07/09/23 11:20PM
Shaded_Cube said:
For the most part, I don't give a fuck want people make. I'm all for freedom of expression. Doesn't matter if like it or not, they can make it. I only delete things based on the rules. You think loli and shota offend me? I've been exposed to way too much for that.


In all honesty, you have the same morals as I do, I don't care for loli or shota nor do I care for porn of characters based on real people, or IRL adults who have the psyche to just get the fuck over it. Again I am only really pissed if real children are involved in the drawn art, or if the art was made to harass people. or if it's deepfake.
Misskitkat_
07/09/23 11:29PM
Edge1 said:
doltscanttag said:
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them

So about 99.8% of all people?


That's the one flaw with the argument, a lot of people hate having porn of themselves drawn on rule34, but so long as we're adults with a developed brain and psyche and are able to ignore it, we can just move on with our lives.


You say this as a person who has no porn drawn of them. "Get over it" is the advice you'd give to someone who feels sexually harassed by obscene images of themself?
Edge1
07/09/23 11:32PM
Misskitkat_ said:
Edge1 said:
doltscanttag said:
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them

So about 99.8% of all people?


That's the one flaw with the argument, a lot of people hate having porn of themselves drawn on rule34, but so long as we're adults with a developed brain and psyche and are able to ignore it, we can just move on with our lives.


You say this as a person who has no porn drawn of them. "Get over it" is the advice you'd give to someone who feels sexually harassed by obscene images of themself?


My point is, if you're an adult, and you are able to ignore it, aren't spam DMed the porn, or isn't having any kind of revenge porn made of them. You should move on, as complaining about the porn will only get more porn of you drawn. Also, I do have porn of me, but it's private because the artist prefers to keep it private, and it's their right to do so because the artist (unless I commission them) owns the art and they can do whatever they want with it.
Misskitkat_
07/09/23 11:41PM
Edge1 said:
Misskitkat_ said:
Edge1 said:
doltscanttag said:
gusfring456 said:
One thing i really dont like though is drawing porn of people who don't want porn made of them

So about 99.8% of all people?


That's the one flaw with the argument, a lot of people hate having porn of themselves drawn on rule34, but so long as we're adults with a developed brain and psyche and are able to ignore it, we can just move on with our lives.


You say this as a person who has no porn drawn of them. "Get over it" is the advice you'd give to someone who feels sexually harassed by obscene images of themself?


My point is, if you're an adult, and you are able to ignore it, aren't spam DMed the porn, or isn't having any kind of revenge porn made of them. You should move on, as complaining about the porn will only get more porn of you drawn. Also, I do have porn of me, but it's private because the artist prefers to keep it private, and it's their right to do so because the artist (unless I commission them) owns the art and they can do whatever they want with it.


So, yes, "get over it, don't feel harassed."
1 2345>>>


Reply | Forum Index